Jenn
VI Desserts St Thomas – Magical Tropical Delights
I am a lucky girl! Scott and Nicci asked me to pay a visit to the St. Thomas Blog’s newest advertiser, VI Desserts, to talk to Stacy Nicastro about her sweet business and to sample some of her homemade desserts. As you know, the St. Thomas Blog is all about dishing honest opinions, even of its advertisers, so a treats tasting was mandatory. As a dessert lover this project was right up my alley.
VI Desserts is located in Red Hook, tucked away in a warehouse building on the way to Compass Point. I might have missed the small industrial kitchen had the VI Desserts sign and the aroma of baked goods not led the way.

As I arrived to the small kitchen a petite woman wearing a colorful bandanna over her hair emerged to greet me. I had met Stacy, the bandana’ed baker, a few days earlier while she was delivering desserts to Shipwreck Tavern, one of the many restaurants on St. Thomas that feature VI Desserts delicacies on its menu. Restaurant patrons, myself included, ooh’ed and ah’ed as a decadent chocolate dessert was lifted out of the bakery box and carefully placed in the display case. The waitress told me that VI Desserts makes the best desserts on the island, and I was eager to find out for myself.
Stacy led me into her “office”, a tiny, well-organized industrial kitchen, featuring a Kitchen Aid mixer, a walk-in refrigerator and matching walk-in freezer, tall ovens, and a Hobart mixer. It’s hard to believe that only two women, Stacy and Jessica Gabelhausen, are able to create magical desserts in such a small space.
I immediately spotted a platter of sweets artfully arranged on the counter, and, as much as I wanted to grab a fork and dig in, I contained myself long enough to ask Stacy a few questions about her background and her business.
A self-taught baker, pastry chef, and cook, Stacy moved to St. Thomas from Wisconsin in March 1996 to join her parents who were already on the island. She worked as a bartender at Romano’s and then at Marina Market, where her homemade desserts became a hit. As she grew more familiar with the restaurant industry, she knew that she was ready to venture out on her own. Being a savvy business woman, Stacy decided to reduce her overhead costs and operate VI Desserts as a wholesale bakery available to the public on a made-to-order basis.
At VI Desserts most recipes has been adapted to fit the Caribbean favor and available ingredients. Stacy “wanted to bring something new to St. Thomas. To introduce the island locals to new flavors and to satisfy stateside residents with a taste of home.” She created a fun menu featuring such unique sweets as Peanut Butter and Jelly cake, Elvis Impersonation cake, Mint Meltdown cake, Red White and Blue Velvet cake, as well as more traditional treats like Ginger Snap cookies and Chocolate Chip cookies. The focal point of the business is wedding and special occasion cakes, but Stacy and Jessica bake local favorites daily to be featured at establishments such as Buddha Sushi, Current Cut, Lattes in Paradise, Wikked, Fat Turtle, Badass Coffee, and Marina Market. All VI Desserts are made to order and everything is made fresh from scratch. To see the full VI Desserts menu, visit www.videsserts.com.
Now, to the fun part. Tasting.
I don’t know about you, but there have been plenty of times that I have salivated over a gorgeous cake, cookie, or pastry only to find that the presentation was far more appetizing that the actual baked good. VI Desserts has a knack for creating beautiful treats, but would the flavor and texture match the presentation? Fork in hand, I decided to start with the Mint Meltdown cake, as Stacy had told me it is one of her favorites. My fork slide through the moist devil’s food chocolate cake, white chocolate mint butter cream filling, and chocolate ganache. One bite and I was hooked. The cake was rich and smooth. All the flavors mixed for a minty taste explosion. And, a little sugar rush…the sign of a perfect dessert.
Next, I sampled the Red White and Blue Velvet cake. Again, the cake was moist and the strawberry filling was incredible. But, what struck me most was the smooth, creamy butter cream frosting that melted in my mouth. As a butter cream frosting lover (I will confess that I would eat Crisco out of the can as a toddler), I can honestly write that this is the best butter cream frosting I have ever tasted. So good, in fact, that I had to ask Stacy her secret. Italian Butter Cream. It’s lighter than traditional, made with fresh butter and meringue (whipped egg whites and sugar). No shortening or artificial flavors here. It’s the only butter cream recipe used at VI Desserts. And, it’s sensational.
Sugar pumping through my system, I took a bite of the lemon coconut cake with white chocolate butter cream frosting. Heaven. I next sampled a piece of the Turtle Bar, a rich chocolate butter pecan treat that is sure to cure even the grandest chocolate craving. If you’re in need of a chocolate fix, head over to Fat Turtle, which features the Turtle Bar on its dessert menu. Stacy pointed to the “Chewy” Macadamia Bar, a local favorite since her days at Marina Market, where her macadamia bars are still sold. I can understand why this treat is a favorite. This tropical bar blends coconut and macadamia nuts into a perfect, rich, gooey delight. I finished my morning tasting with a bite of Ginger Snap cookie, which features three different types of ginger. Sweet, crisp, and distinct. This cookie rocks.
Stacy sent me away from VI Desserts with a tray of dessert heaven, to continue my sampling and indulging on Coconut bread, Orange Pumpkin bread, Oatmeal “Crazy” cookies, and, of course, the remainder of all my morning tasting treats. Yum! I arrived at the office and was “attacked” by two men, forks in hand, ready for their own mid-morning sugar rush. “Oh WOW!” “SO Good!” “Delicious!” were some of the comments they made between mouthfuls of cake, cookies, and bread. Within an hour, the homemade desserts were gone, polished off by two men who are now very big fans of VI Desserts.
VI Desserts specializes in wedding and special occassion made-to-order cakes as well as servicing the dessert needs of many St. Thomas dining establishments, but you can get your hands on some tasty treats even if you don’t have a special occassion. Stacy and Jessica bake homemade goodies everyday for the public. If you have a hankering for some homemade delicacies, call VI Desserts at (340) 643-3763 to place your order. Just be prepared to become a VI Desserts addict!
Full Disclosure: VI Desserts is a paid advertiser on the St. Thomas Blog. But trust us when we say it had no bearing on how good their desserts are!










































